EVANSVILLE | VANDERBURGH COUNTY AREA PLAN COMMISSION ANNUAL REPORT 2015

2015 BY THE NUMBERS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

APC 2015 Budget
$735,677.00

Fees Returned
$454,695.67

Zoning Code Filings
33 Rezonings
85 Variances
35 Special Uses

Zoning Enforcement
1,953 complaint site inspections followed up by
890 violation letters sent
Subdivisions
54 Plats Filed
47 Plats Recorded and 13 Parcelizations creating 404 new lots/parcels
81 Letters of Credit for improvements with a value of over $5.3 million

Permitting
1,881 total permits issued
709 new housing units were permitted (306 single-family & 403 multi-family).

Site Review
241 plans reviewed by the Site Review Committee.
The following amendments to the City/County Subdivision Codes were adopted in 2015: The expiration of primary plat approval, The letter of credit requirements for subdivision public improvements, and Addressing sidewalk requirements and waivers.

PURPOSE OF REPORT

The purpose of this annual report fulfills the statutory duties of the Area Plan Commission Executive Director as listed in Indiana Code IC 36-7-4-312:

  1. Propose annually a plan for the operation of the planning department;
  2. Prepare and present to the commission an annual report.

FUNCTIONS OF AREA PLAN COMMISSION (APC)

The Area Plan Commission meetings are on the second Thursday of each month. The following are typical agenda items heard by the Plan Commission:

  • Requests for city and county rezonings
  • Requests for primary subdivision approval for plats and replats
  • Requests to amend the City and County Zoning and Subdivision Ordinances
  • Reports from staff

Table 1 shows the data on the number of development proposals filed and the actions taken by the APC in 2015.

FUNCTIONS OF BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS

The Board of Zoning Appeals meetings are on the third Thursday of each month. The following are typical agenda items heard by the BZA:

  • Requests for Variances from one or more of the Zoning Code requirements
  • Requests for Special Uses which by their nature cannot be classified in the usual residential, commercial, or industrial zoning districts
  • Requests to amend the City and County Zoning and Subdivision Ordinances
  • Appeals by a petitioner of decisions made by administrative staff, administrative board, or other bodies (except for the Plan Commission itself), in relation to enforcement and/or interpretation of the Zoning Ordinance or issuance of Improvement Location Permits

See Table 1 for information relative to the number of variance and special use requests heard by the Board of Zoning Appeals

AREA PLAN COMMISSION STAFF

  • Executive Director – Ronald S. London, P.E., CFM
  • Assistant Director/Planner - Blaine Oliver
  • Senior Planner - John Ansbro, AICP
  • Zoning Administrator – Janet Greenwell
  • Zoning Enforcement Officer – Donna Holderfield
  • Zoning Enforcement Officer – Ward Pedley III (part of 2015)
  • Zoning Enforcement Officer – Karen Pickett (part of 2015)
  • Zoning Investigator - Joel Wiegand
  • Chief Draftsman - Brenda Hill
  • GIS Administrator / Web Developer - Ryan Key
  • CAD/GIS Specialist - Jim McReynolds
  • Bookkeeper/Office Manager - Karen Yokel
  • Senior Secretary - April Sprague (part of 2015)
  • Attorney – Dirck Stahl

TABLE 1 REQUESTS & FINAL ACTIONS

Area Plan Commssion

ACTION REZONINGS MAJOR SUBDIVISIONS MINOR SUBDIVISIONS SUBDIVISION WAIVERS
 201320142015201320142015201320142015201320142015
Number Filed46334171593940455430
Approved34364066 3635 23 
Denied12000 14 20 
Withdrawn32101 24 00 
No Action302         
Approved by Legistative Body253637        

Board of Zoning Appeals

ACTION VARIANCE SPECIAL USE
 201320142015201320142015
Number Filed8885103413548
Approved889186353645
Denied332000
Withdrawn324040

FINANCING

The Area Plan Commission is financed by annual appropriations from Vanderburgh County and the City of Evansville. The total budget split in 2015 was 85% County and 15% City.

Information concerning the 2015 Budget and Disbursements is provided in Table 2. Table 3 displays the amount fees collected by Area Plan Commission for all revenue items.

WORK ACCOMPLISHED IN 2015

COMPREHENSIVE PLAN

Work on an update of the current Comprehensive Plan continued in 2015. A Draft of a new Plan for Year 2035 was produced and distributed to the APC and the public in 2015. Four public meetings were held on the new draft Plan to obtain comments from City and County residents. The next step to complete the process is to hold a set of adoption hearings on the Plan update.

ZONING ORDINANCE

In 2015, the Area Plan Commission staff continued to research, write staff field reports, and provide verbal comments at the Area Plan Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals meetings on each proposed rezoning, variance, special use, and appeal.

The review of rezoning, variance, and special use petitions is a significant aspect of the Area Plan Commission’s efforts to administer the Zoning Ordinance.

Table 1 displays the number of these petitions filed in 2015, and the action taken by the Area Plan Commission. Table 5 shows the acreage of the approved rezonings.

ZONING ENFORCEMENT

The Evansville-Vanderburgh County area has three Zoning Enforcement/Investigator Officers .In 2015, there were approximately 1,953 complaint site inspections and, when warranted, these inspections were followed by issuance of almost 890 Zoning Code violation letters.

SITE REVIEW PROCESS

The Site Review Committee is another of the ongoing review boards of the Area Plan Commission. This Committee meets weekly to review plans for all new commercial development, industrial development, all other non-residential uses, and apartment complexes, prior to issuance of improvement location permits.

In 2015, applicants filed 225 site development plans for review. Of the total number of plans reviewed, 82 percent of these sites are located in the City and 18 percent in the County.Pending and Recently approved projects can be viewed using the Project Status web mapping application.

TABLE 2 BUDGET & DISBURSEMENTS

Budget Added Appropriations Transfers Expended or Encumbered Returned and Repealed
Salary of Employees$566,408.00 $2,990.00$569,398.00 
      
Social Security, PERF$106,769.00  $105,744.00$1,025.00
      
Fuel$1,500.00 $1,000.00$1,231.25$1,268.75
      
Garage and Motor$500.00  $494.49$5.51
      
Supplies$4,500.00 $464.55$2,941.05$2,023.50
      
Postage/Freight$2,000.00  $1,162.37$837.63
      
Travel/Mileage$1,500.00  $1,500.00$0.00
      
Communications$6,000.00 $5,500.00$11,210.00$290.00
      
Training and Education$2,500.00  $1,135.45$1,364.55
      
Printing$500.00  $500.00$0.00
      
Legal Advertising$2,000.00  $1,346.41$653.59
      
Maintenance and Repair$500.00  $0.00$500.00
      
Rent$55,631.00  $52,981.80$2,649.20
      
Legal Services$35,000.00 $3,000.00$30,353.33$1,646.67
      
Equipment Lease and Repair$4,500.00  $4,099.60$400.40
      
Dues and Subscriptions$1,500.00  $1,423.00$77.00
      
Office Machines$0.00  $0.00$0.00
TOTAL$791,308.00$3,964.55 $785,520.75$5,788.00

TABLE 3 REVENUE FROM FEES

YEAR CITY COUNTY TOTAL
2011$113,343.00 $45,936.00 $159,279.00
2012$115,265.00 $45,572.00 $160,837.00
2013$116,927.00 $47,191.00 $164,118.00
2014$221,618.78 $75,286.20 $296,904.98
2015$314,219.25 $140,476.42 $454,695.67

TABLE 4 AREA PLAN ACTIVITY 2005-2015

Improvement Location Permits are not displayed in graph do to much greater values.


ACTIVITY TYPE YEARS
20052006200720082009201020112012201320142015
Subdivisions Filed 50 47 43 43 29 35 40 39 46 55 54
Subdivisions Recorded 59 44 42 40 14 18 34 48 43 47 47
Improvement Location Permits 2,292 2,227 1,930 1,903 1,613 1,613 2,334 1,929 1,976 1,992 1,881
Rezonings Filed 46 45 42 43 25 27 22 28 46 33 41
Special Uses Filed 44 30 33 31 40 45 38 40 41 35 48
Variances Filed 84 94 95 95 71 76 79 88 80 85 103

TABLE 5 ACREAGE OF APPROVED REZONINGS


ZONING DISTRICT CITY ACREAGE COUNTY ACREAGE TOTALS
 201320142015201320142015201320142015
Agricultural0003.6502.53.6502.5
Single Family0.612.4644.4434.79044.4535.42.4688.89
Multi-Family5.041.715.72144.250204.69149.291.7220.41
PUD000000000
Commercial9.593668.86119.0634.680.03128.6570.6148.89
Industrial10.2621.051.5814.105.0824.3621.056.66
Air000000000
Totals25.561.21130.6315.8534.6336.75341.3595.81467.35

SITE REVIEW PROJECTS

Some examples of multi-family and commercial projects
reviewed by the Commercial Site Review Committee throughout 2015

CITY PROJECTS

  • HOUSING
    • Weinbach Manor Apartments, 2015 N Weinbach Ave., 1 building - 8 units
    • Meridan Plaza, 300 Main St., remodel 9 apartment units
  • COMMERCIAL
    • Hotel, 20 E. Walnut St., remodel 76 rooms
    • Home 2 Suites, 7901 E Walnut St., 4 story hotel – 102 rooms
    • Holiday Inn Express, 300 Kirkwood, 4 story hotel – 92 rooms
    • Schnucks Grocery Store, 800 S Green River Rd., 59,000 sq ft retail + another 8,080 sqft
    • Walmart Market & gas station, 2500 N. First Ave., 41,117 sqft retail building
    • Haier America Refrigerators, 900 W Indiana St., remodel 45,772 sqft warehouse to office & factory
    • DPatrick Auto Dealership & Service Center, 1100 E Walnut St., 34,922 sqft building
    • Zaxby’s Restaurant, 1021 Burkhardt Rd., 90 seats

COUNTY PROJECTS

  • HOUSING
    • Evansville Health Campus North, 811E. Baseline Rd., 30 unit nursing home
  • COMMERCIAL
    • Scott Township Fire,12841 S.R.57, 9,120 sqft new fire station
    • Oak Hill Middle and Scott Elementary Schools, 77000 Oak Hill Rd. & 14940 Old State Rd.; 5 portable classrooms
    • WalMart SuperCenter, 12100 SR 57, 189,543 sqft retail building
    • Schnucks Grocery Store, 12920 Old State Rd., 59,472 sqft retail + another 14,098 sqft retail building
    • Crossroads IGA Grocery Store & gas station, 6401 N Green River Rd., 10,113 sqft reatail building
    • FedEx Distribution Center, 15200 N Hwy 41, 255,092 sqft building

ISSUANCE OF PERMITS

The Area Plan Commission issues improvement location permits for residential, commercial, and industrial uses before construction activity can begin. In 2015, the Plan Commission processed a total of 1,881 applications for improvement location permits.

Table 6 displays a count of the permits issued by consolidated permit categories. Table 8 shows the number Housing Units permitted by township. 2015 was a good year for multi-family development in the city, especially in Knight and Pigeon Townships.

TABLE 6 IMPROVEMENT LOCATION PERMITS


CITY COUNTY TOTALS
201120122013201420152011201220132014201520112012201320142015
Single Family 9437549452163201239214254257238293308306
                
Multi Family                
Permits73471214511159218152121
Units21975891013733431222633253106111127406
                
Additions & Remodeling | residential & commercial275286192303235134114140141108409400332444343
                
Accessory Structures | garages, swimming pools, Ag bldgs 869792118116175180174168262261277266286378
                
Commercial & Industrial Bldg63631443932081111956395550
                
Change-Of-Use / Business 4472252532072152426161917471251269226232
                
Signs - on-premise & temporary7755946645664288374785555858668742621483
                
Others - temporary uses3621162155111049134731203068
                
TOTAL1,7271,2991,3061,3601,1526076306706327292,3341,9291,9761,9921,881

SUBDIVISION REVIEW PROCESS

As designated by State law, the Area Plan Commission has sole authority over the subdivision process.

In the review of a primary subdivision plat, the Area Plan Commission determines whether the plat complies with standards in the Subdivision Code. The Area Plan Commission has delegated the authority to grant secondary plat approval to the Executive Director.

Secondary approval also has multiple requirements that must be met prior to recording the plat. One example involves submittal of a Letter of Credit ensuring that all subdivision improvements are installed by the developer in accordance with City/ County standards. As of December 31, 2015, the Area Plan Commission held 81 active letters of credit for subdivision improvements with a total value of over $5.3 million

Table 1 shows the numerous major and minor subdivision actions taken, while Table 7 shows descriptive data on the 47 subdivisions recorded in 2015.

Staff also worked on amendments to the County Subdivision Code in 2015 that addressed:

  • Expiration of primary plat approval;
  • Sidewalk issues including: options for the letters of credit or installation before issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, and procedures for waivers.

TABLE 7 RECORDED SUBDIVISIONS


CITY COUNTY TOTAL
 201320142015201320142015201320142015
Subdivisions142016292731434747
Parcelizations  11491217913
Lots/Parcels464873199138331245186404
Acreage (Sub Lots)466880152135200198203280
Average Lot Size (Acres)11.451.130.831.120.680.871.210.77

TABLE 8 PERMITTED HOUSING UNITS


Township Single Family Multi-Family TOTALS
 201120122013201420152011201220132014201520112012201320142015
ARMSTRONG213340000021334
                
CENTER               
City12222634760010182226357
Unincorporated431041199310411216101254106135103116
Total5512614512711117216111272128161138123
                
GERMAN67108691000015171086
                
KNIGHT               
City1142144332293883240133359127273
Unincorporated0060210150600156621
Total1142744542443889240134865133294
                
PERRY               
City1001100018121001913
Unincorporated1181723401626662710232946
Total128172441162626182810234859
                
PIGEON54107151121146510121265565815132
                
SCOTT | Includes Darmstadt44808187790004124480819191
                
UNION000000000000000
                
EVANSVILLE78365494522197589102373297111143196425
Unincorporated1062002392142543629222633142229261240287
COUNTY TOTAL184236293308306255104111128406439340404436612

INFORMATION AND TECHNOLOGY

GIS WEB MAPPING AND APPLICATIONS

The Area Plan Commission continued to support IT/GIS operations in 2015 by maintaining numerous GIS layers along with the development of several mapping applications.

GIS PROJECT ASSISTANCE

Area Plan continued to assist various departments on GIS related projects including the Building Commission; DMD, Vanderburgh County Assessor and several others.

Area Plan is responsible for the update and maintenance of the following GIS Data:

  • All Annotation – Property Dimensions, Lot Numbers, Addresses.
  • APC Errata – Layer indicating land division not meeting Subdivision Code requirements.
  • Deed Lot – Land division created by way of deed.
  • Easements – Easement location and type.
  • Parcels – Parcel Boundaries maintained in conjunction with County Assessors.
  • ROW – Road, railroad, and vacations of rights of way.
  • Street Network – Street network data and address ranges.
  • Special Use Docket – Special Use filing boundaries.
  • Subdivisions – Recorded subdivision boundaries both minor and major.
  • Sub Lot –Subdivision parcel lot lines.
  • Zoning – Zoning petition boundaries and classification.
  • Zones With Conditions – Identifies zoning petitions with specific conditions.

Currently the existing City/County GIS maps are not accessible from mobile devices. APC has developed and begun beta testing a mobile ready and responsive zoning map as a replacement for the current zoning map. Zoning Map (Beta)

COMMITTEE PARTICIPATION

The APC Executive Director and staff serve on the following committees beyond the Subdivision and Site Review:

  • Downtown Design Review
  • Evansville MPO Technical
  • Flood Advisory
  • Local Emergency Planning
  • Pigeon Creek Greenway Advisory
  • GIS Technical Committee

CENSUS

The Area Plan Commission holds the designation as a State data center affiliate for the Evansville Metropolitan Statistical Area, and is a depository for Census data. The APC routinely disseminates this information as a public service. Census statistical information has been added to our web page Comprised of tabular data and web mapping applications.

PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION

To increase staff knowledge on information that will allow the Plan Commission to better serve City/County residents, the APC staff received training in online webinars. Several of the staff members participate in continuing education programs on an ongoing basis to meet professional certification requirements, such as for the American Institute of Certified Planners, Certified Floodplain Managers, Professional Engineers, and GIS.

APC WORK PROGRAM FOR 2016

  • Comprehensive Plan Update Review & Adoption:
  • View Draft
    • Set hearings with the APC and elected bodies to adopt final plan
    • Start working on accomplishing Plan policies listed in the first 5-years of implementation

Develop and adopt Rules of Procedure for APC & BZA

Document qualifying CRS activities to stay eligible for the program

Coordinate on Other Planning Efforts (Redevelopment Plans, University Parkway Corridor Plan, etc.)

Form a University Parkway Corridor Study Group for a corridor study involving possible overlay zones, a technology park, etc. – this would require some County funding

  • Zoning Code Updates
    • Electronic Message Board Signage
    • Accessory Structures -- Allow to be larger than principal use in footprint & height (County only)
    • Ownership Property Line Adjustments and Lots of Record
    • Wireless Telecommunications Ordinance
    • Allowing Staff Approval of Minor PUD Changes
    • Temporary Sign Exemptions to Sign Requirements (County only)
    • Buffer Yards for Commercial/Industrial Uses
  • Subdivision Code Updates:
    • Adding Standards on Safety & other Issues
    • Rewrite existing Subdivision Procedures
  • GIS Initiative
    • Complete georeferencing of lot of record scanned images.
    • Create raster overlay of lots of record georeferenced data.
    • Create Parcelizations GIS Layer.
    • Continue to develop mobile accessible zoning mapping application.
    • Train Staff to Edit APC Errata GIS Layer.
    • Create Subdivision Review App.
    • Finalize online permit application form and map extension.
    • Continue Expansion of GIS Open Data and availability.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

MAYOR - 2015

Honorable Lloyd Winnecke.

CITY COUNCIL - 2015

  • Dr. H. Dan Adams, President
  • John Friend, Vice President
  • Al Lindsey
  • Conor O’Daniel
  • Dan McGinn
  • Missy Mosby
  • Constance Robinson
  • Jonathan Weaver
  • Stephanie Brinkerhoff-Riley

COUNTY COMMISSIONERS - 2015

  • Joe Kiefer, President
  • Bruce Ungethiem
  • Stephen Melcher

COUNTY COUNCIL - 2015

  • Angela Koehler Lindsey, President
  • John Montrastelle, Vice-President
  • Ed Bassemier
  • Mike Goebel
  • Jim Raben
  • Stephanie Terry

DARMSTADT TOWN BOARD - 2015

  • Bob Stobbs, President
  • Mallory Lowe, Clerk-Treasurer
  • Steve Kahre
  • John Sanders
  • Paul Freeman

AREA PLAN COMMISSION - 2015

  • Stacy Stevens, President
  • Bill Pedtke, Vice Pres.
  • Dr. H. Dan Adams
  • Dewey Colter
  • Marty Amsler
  • Roger Lehman
  • Lynn Lowe
  • Jeffrey Mueller
  • Jeffrey Mueller
  • Joy Payne
  • Paul Kumar
  • John Montrastelle
  • Bruce Ungethiem

BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEMBERS - 2015

  • Stacy Stevens
  • Cheryl Musgrave
  • Jonathan Parkhurst
  • Bill Pedtke
  • Becky Kasha
  • Gregg Utley
  • Mike Zehner

Permits & Applications Map Summary

Note: Not all permits and applications taken in have location data that can be used to place it on the map or the location data no longer exists.

This maps serves as an approximation of activity.